The plaintiff, Mrs. Chinn, agreed with her neighbor, Ms. Hess, to build a common fence. The worker hired to construct it found he had to trim the branches of one of Mrs. Chinn’s plum trees to make the fence fit. And that’s where the problems arose.
Mrs. Chinn’s tenants, the Schmidts, told the worker to go ahead and cut down the tree. Of course, they denied this, but the trial court found the testimony of the worker and four neighbors who watched the timber harvest unfold. Mrs. Chinn sued Forrest and Hess for trespass and for treble damages for wrongful tree cutting under California statute.
The issue was whether Forrest and Hess reasonably believed the Schmidts had the authority to speak for Mrs. Chinn. The trial court found that the authority Mrs. Chinn had given them, coupled with her own ignoring of the goings-on in the fence and tree project, gave the defendants a reasonable basis to believe that the Schmidts could give Forrest the right to cut down the tree.
Thus, there was no trespass. And, of course, no trees left standing, either.
A common fence
Chinn v. Hess, 2007 Cal. App. Unpub. LEXIS 3942, 2007 WL 1430192 (Cal.App. 1 Dist., May 16, 2007). Chinn and Hess owned adjoining properties. Chinn rented her place to the Schmidts. Chinn and Hess agreed to build a new fence and hired Forrest to complete it. While he was building it, he cut down a plum tree on Chinn’s land that obstructed the planned fence.
Chinn sued Hess and Forrest for trespass and wrongful tree cutting under California Code of Civil Procedure § 733. Forrest claimed he had begun merely by trimming the tree, but the Schmidts came outside and agreed the tree should come down. The Schmidts denied this, but the weight of the evidence caused the trial court to believe Mr. Forrest.
The trial court found for Hess and Forrest. Chinn appealed.
Held: The plum tree remained cut down (of course, it would have at any rate), but Mrs. Chinn was not entitled to treble damages under California Code of Civil Procedure 733. The trial court had found that Mrs. Chinn hadn’t proved that Forrest had proceeded without consent, but Mrs. Chinn complained that it wasn’t her obligation to prove lack of consent; it was Forrest’s and Hess’s duty to prove they had consent.
The plum tree was very severely pruned.
The Court of Appeals held that lack of consent is an element of the tort of trespass, meaning that it was one of the issues Mrs. Chinn had to prove to establish a trespass. Still, whether she carried her burden of proof wasn’t important here, the Court said, because the trial court had concluded that Forrest and Hess had proven that the defendants reasonably believed the Schmidts were Mrs. Chinn’s agents. Mrs. Chinn had given the Schmidts authority to speak to Ms. Hess about the tree and the fence. Once the Schmidts were empowered to speak for Plaintiff, Plaintiff chose not to communicate with Defendant Marilyn Hess, and when the issue of the plum tree arose, Mrs. Chinn did not respond to messages and did not drive two miles to see the fence. Rather, Mrs. Chinn relied solely on the Schmidts to represent her regarding the fence and tree issue, just as she relied upon them to take care of the garden on the property they were renting.
The combination of Mrs. Chinn’s intentional conduct and her want of ordinary care caused Forrest and Hess to reasonably believe that the Schmidts had authority to consent to the removal of the tree. Ostensible authority in an agent is established by showing that the principal, intentionally or by want of ordinary care has caused or allowed a third person to believe the agent possesses such authority. Such authority must be established through the acts or declarations of the principal and not the acts or declarations of the agent. Where the principal, like Mrs. Chinn, knows that the agent holds himself out as clothed with a certain authority and remains silent, such conduct may give rise to liability.
You can see why Hocking Hills is a good place for a park.
I’m always looking for ideas, and I am rather shameless about appropriating them. So when an Ohio lawyer friend, himself from a timber-harvesting family, mentioned a case that delineated when trees were attached to the real estate and when they were “goods,” I chased down the decision. Or, in this case, the decisions – one from the court of appeals, and a second from the Ohio Supreme Court.
Speaking of “appropriating,” that was exactly the context in which the case was decided. It seems that Dudley DeBolt had a pretty nice place inHocking County, beautiful Appalachian foothill country. In fact, Dudley’s place was so nice the government wanted it for a park. Governments being what they are, the appropriate agency – an entity called theBoard of Park Commissioners of the Columbus and Franklin County Metropolitan Park District– sued Dudley to take 40 acres of his wooded land for its purposes.
Under the laws governingeminent domain, not to mention the5th Amendment, when the government takes private property for public purposes, it must pay just compensation. But it seems that the Park Board didn’t want to pay Dudley for the timber contract he had already signed with a local timber merchant, one for the selective cutting of about 150,000 board feet of hardwood. The land itself was worth $58,000, Dudley claimed, but there was also the timber contract that he now would be unable to fulfill, for an additional $14,000.
Nope, the Park Board argued, the trees are attached to the land and had no value separate from the land. That had been Ohio law prior to the adoption of theUniform Commercial Code. The trial court agreed with the Park Board.
The Court of Appeals did not. Rather, it held that the UCC had changed everything, and as a result, Dudley was given a chance to prove to the jury the existence and value of the timber contract. The Ohio Supreme Court agreed, and the case went back to the trial court.
Board of Park Comm’rs v DeBolt, 1984 WL 4248 (Ct.App. Hocking County, Ohio, 1984). The Board of Park Commissioners of the Columbus and Franklin County Metropolitan Park District sued landowner Dudley DeBolt, Jr., to appropriate 40 acres of his land. Mr. DeBolt believed the fair market value of the land was $73,970, including $32,000 for the land at $800 an acre, $26,000 for the home, and $14,000 for his profit from removing certain timber on the property. The trial court agreed with the Park Board that Mr. DeBolt could not calculate the value of his standing timber separately from the land, and it refused to allow him to present further evidence of the value of his timber. The jury returned a verdict of $58,000 as compensation for the land and improvements taken. Mr. DeBolt appealed.
Held: Mr. DeBolt was allowed to value the timber separately. Although the Board argued that Ohio law prohibited setting a market value for trees on land to be appropriated separate and apart from the value of the land, the Court noted that the decision applying that holding was made well before Ohio’s adoption of the Uniform Commercial Code. The UCC provides that a “contract for the sale apart from the land of growing crops or other things attached to realty and capable of severance without material harm thereto… or of timber to be cut is a contract for the sale of goods withinsections 1302.01 to 1302.98 of the Revised Code, whether the subject matter is to be severed by the buyer or by the seller even though it forms part of the realty at the time of contracting, and the parties can by identification effect a present sale before severance.” Thus, the Court ruled, the UCC had abrogated prior Ohio law by making a contract for the sale of timber into a contract for the sale of goods.
Here, the evidence showed that in the summer of 1981, a timber merchant and DeBolt had a contract to cut timber and had agreed on a price. Therefore, the Court said, DeBolt ought to have had the right to prove the existence and value of the timber contract. It was a contract for the sale of goods, and DeBolt thus had a vested contractual right which was frustrated by the Park Board’s appropriation. The Court said that “the enactment of the UCC has in our opinion changed the character of standing timber from realty to personalty when there is a contract underR.C. 1302.03.” Once the contract was made, the trees were “goods” under the UCC and no longer a part of the land.
People who have to pay attention to the bottom line make careful decisions about whether appealing an adverse decision is worth the time and legal costs. Not so governments, which hire lawyers by the gross and pay them with taxpayer dollars. Unhappy at having to part with an additional $14,000, the Board of Park Commissioners appealed to the Ohio Supreme Court. Even in 1984, a for-profit entity would have easily seen that legal fees and wasted time would easily exceed that.
Board of Park Comm’rs v DeBolt, 15 Ohio St.3d 376 (Supreme Court of Ohio 1984). The Ohio Supreme Court agreed with the Court of Appeals that the record supported a finding that a contract may have existed for the sale of the timber. The Supreme Court found some evidence that Dudley DeBolt was to receive $14,000 for the sale of some 150,000 board feet of lumber, and that such lumber was to be obtained in a select cutting, which was permitted under the terms of his mother’s will. The timber cutter said 150,000 board feet of lumber could be obtained in a select cutting and stated that he had first surveyed the property some eighteen months prior to the trial.
The Supreme Court ruled that a contract for the sale of timber is a contract for the sale of goods, not realty. ORC § 1302.03(B). Such a contract is protected against a governmental taking without just compensation, as it was part of the property taken by the Board of Park Commissioners. Because such a contract is an asset separate and apart from the land, it is subject to separate valuation. The case was sent back to the trial court to give Dudley a chance to prove his case.
Only in California could a tree-trimming case become a free speech issue.
Our regular readers know that good old-fashioned Massachusetts Rule self-help is available to any homeowner seeking to protect life and property from encroaching trees. Today, we look at what happens when good old-fashioned common-law self-help runs into bureaucracy.
The Dilbecks wanted to add a second story to their house, but their neighbors’ oak tree had extended its branches so close to the Dilbecks’ place that they had to be trimmed back in order to make room. No problem, right? We all know that self-help is available to the Dilbecks anywhere in California. Sure, but it turns out that Los Angeles isn’t just anywhere. In LA, oak trees are “protected,” and before trimming the oak, the Dilbecks had to get a permit from the County. And the County wouldn’t issue a permit unless the tree’s owner signed on to it.
So much for self-help. The Dilbecks sued, asking that the County be ordered to issue the permit and that their neighbors be found liable for trespass for the tree (the theory being that the neighbors let the branches intrude over the Dilbecks’ lawn). And here’s where it got even more complicated. California has a statute addressing litigation known as “strategic lawsuits against public participation,” the so-calledanti-SLAPP statute. This mouthful, with the catchy name, is intended to stop oppressive lawsuits meant to keep people from exercising their right to free speech. There’s a whole cottage industry in the Golden State surrounding SLAPP actions. And as with a lot of other good ideas (such as RICO), the anti-SLAPP statute is another tool in the canny lawyer’s arsenal, something else with which to bludgeon a plaintiff.
Here, the neighbors complained that the Dilbecks were trying to force them to petition the County to let the tree get trimmed, and the suit should be thrown out as violating the anti-SLAPP statute. The trial court refused to dismiss the action. The Court of Appeals agreed, holding that the Dilbecks weren’t demanding that the neighbors do anything. They were asking the County to do something, and they were suing the neighbors for trespass because of the tree. California law would let them collect money damages if the encroaching tree was a nuisance (Bonde v. Bishop held as much). So whether the Dilbecks win on the merits or not, the action was not a SLAPP suit, and it wouldn’t be dismissed.
Whew! Makes you long for the simple, ol’ Massachusetts Rule… no permits, no lawsuits, just an aggrieved landowner with a chainsaw.
Dilbeck v. Van Schaick,2007 Cal. App. Unpub. LEXIS 7718, 2007 WL 2773986 (Cal.App. 2 Dist., Sept. 25, 2007). The Dilbecks owned a place in Altadena, next door to the Van Schaicks. The Dilbecks planned to remodel their home by adding a second story. However, branches of an oak tree on the Van Schaicks’ property had grown over the Dilbecks’ home, making their plans unworkable unless the tree was pruned.
Oak trees are protected by California state law. The County of Los Angeles had adopted regulations to preserve and protect oak trees, requiring a permit to cut down mature oak trees or to prune their larger branches. The Dilbecks applied to the County for a permit, but the County had not approved it because it took the position that only the tree owner may obtain a pruning permit, and the Van Schaicks had not acquiesced. So the Dilbecks brought suit against the Van Schaicks and the County for declaratory relief and trespass. They alleged the oak tree growing on the Van Schaicks’ property had encroached onto their land and interfered with their ability to add a second story to their home. The suit said the County refused to grant the permit because the Dilbecks did not own the tree. The trespass cause of action alleged that the oak tree branches encroached on the Dilbecks’ land and asked for an order permitting the Dilbecks or an independent contractor to prune the tree.
The Van Schaicks filed a special motion to strike pursuant to the anti-SLAPP statute,Code of Civil Procedure §425.16, asserting that the complaint was based on their refusal to support the Dilbecks’ oak tree permit application and therefore attacked their right to free speech. They further argued that the trespass claim lacked merit because the law forbade the Van Schaicks from pruning or cutting the offending oak tree branches.
The Dilbecks contended that their action did not fit within the definition of a SLAPP suit and that, in any event, their complaint had merit. They denied that the complaint sought to compel the Van Schaicks to support or sign the oak tree permit. The trial court denied the Van Schaicks’ motion to strike, finding that they had not demonstrated that they were being sued for engaging in protected activity. Instead, the trial court held they were just being sued for trespass. The Van Schaicks appealed the court’s denial of their motion to strike.
Held: The Dilbecks’ complaint did not arise from acts undertaken in furtherance of the Van Schaicks’ rights of free speech or petition, and the Van Schaicks’ attempt to get it dismissed was rejected. The California Legislature enacted the anti-SLAPP statute in response to its perception that lawsuits have increased, brought primarily to chill the valid exercise of the constitutional rights of freedom of speech and petition for the redress of grievances. The anti-SLAPP statute provides a procedure for the court to dismiss, at an early stage, non-meritorious litigation intended to chill the exercise of free speech rights. The statute requires the trial court to engage in a two-step process when determining whether a motion to strike should be granted: first, whether the defendant has made a threshold prima facie showing that the acts of which it complains were ones taken in furtherance of its constitutional rights of petition or free speech in connection with a public issue, and second, whether there is a probability that the plaintiff will prevail on the claim.
The issue here, the Court said, was whether the complaint arose from conduct in furtherance of the exercise of the constitutional right of petition or the constitutional right of free speech in connection with a public issue or an issue of public interest. The Van Schaicks contended the suit sought to compel them to petition the County for discretionary relief from the oak tree statutes. The Court disagreed, holding that their characterization of the complaint was wrong. In fact, the Court said, the suit merely sought to compel the County to review the merits of the permit application submitted by the Dilbecks and requested an order permitting the Dilbecks or their arborist to prune the tree. The complaint did not seek to compel Van Schaicks to become personally involved in the permit application process, and thus did not violate the anti-SLAPP statute.
The Van Schaicks contended that the complaint would indirectly force them to speak because a judgment in favor of the Dilbecks on the trespass action would necessarily require the Van Schaicks to petition the County of Los Angeles for discretionary relief from the Oak Tree statute. The Court rejected that argument, finding that the Van Schaicks’ position was based on the incorrect assumption that the only remedy available for trespass was injunctive relief. However, California law held that a party whose land overhanging branches extend may either cut them off or bring an action for damages and abatement, as long as he or she can prove the branches constitute a nuisance.
The prospect that the Van Schaicks could eventually face an order to abate the nuisance and could do so only by seeking a permit from the County did not transform the Dilbecks’ lawsuit into a SLAPP action. The Court ruled that the thrust of the Dilbecks’ complaint was the injury caused to their property by the encroaching tree, not the Van Schaicks’ decision to refrain from involvement in the permitting process. The permit, although obtainable only by petitioning a governmental entity, principally concerned and affected the remodeling of a private home by private individuals.
The city plans to cut down two dozen diseased and damaged maple trees along Wooster Street — prompting pushback from some neighbors concerned about the removal of so much of the area’s existing canopy. The city’s Parks Department posted removal notices on trees up and down Wooster Street in late October. One such notice — still posted on a tree near the Wooster Street archway — is dated Oct. 29. It states that the city plans to remove that tree because of a “Structural defect that cannot be mitigated or remedied,” “Invasive or noxious species,” and “Decline in health and condition due to non-treatable insects, disease, and/or disorders.” In an email statement sent to the Independent, city Tree Warden Annie Mixsell said, “Many of the maple trees lining Wooster Street are showing signs of stress, damage, and disease. These impacts are the result of urban stress factors, heavy pruning of trees growing under utility wires, and infrastructure upgrades to the sidewalk and roadway that injured root systems…”
We know quite a lot about ancient Mesopotamia, the historical region spanning modern-day Iraq and parts of Syria and Turkey, such as who ruled and the order in which kings succeeded one another. But pinning down exact calendar dates for historical events has been trickier. Now scientists have found a way to narrow down these uncertainties. The technique involves analyzing ancient tree rings and combining this with evidence of volcanic eruptions preserved in ice cores. That’s helping fill important historical gaps, including when Babylon fell. The team, led by Charlotte Pearson of the University of Arizona, began by examining tree-ring patterns in ancient timbers recovered from archaeological sites in what is now Turkey. They measured radioactive carbon levels in individual tree rings and compared the patterns with those found in trees whose exact ages were already known. This gave them precise dates for the ancient wood…
Texas A&M Forest Service has developed an artificial intelligence model that expands access to detailed urban tree canopy maps for communities across Texas, helping cities better understand and manage their tree resources. Developed through the agency’s Spatial Solutions department, the model uses deep learning technology, a type of artificial intelligence that learns to recognize patterns and data, and publicly available aerial imagery to identify tree canopy coverage. It achieved an average overall mapping accuracy of 94.5% when evaluated across 295 Texas municipalities, according to findings detailed in a recently published scientific paper. Urban tree canopy refers to the layer of leaves, branches and stems of trees visible from above. Understanding where tree canopy exists and how it is distributed can help communities make informed decisions about tree planting, urban development and long-term forest management. Trees provide important benefits in urban environments, including reducing temperatures through shade, improving air quality, managing stormwater runoff and lowering building energy demands. Accurate canopy maps help communities assess these resources and identify areas where additional tree coverage may be beneficial…
Residents have won their battle to have a 140-year-old giant tree felled after it repeatedly dropped branches on nearby bungalows. Tree owner Jonathan Rickell appealed to a government planning inspector after Telford & Wrekin Council refused permission to remove the wellingtonia, which dates back to the 1880s. The 21m (70ft) tree is protected by a preservation order, and the council argued its removal would harm the area’s appearance. Planning inspector Elaine Benson visited the site on Lindfield Drive in Wellington in October. She agreed its removal would harm the area’s appearance, but this was outweighed by the damage caused to nearby homes and the risk of more damage from falling branches. The tree, which is also known as a giant redwood, can be seen from far away but stands just metres from bungalows. It has a history of branches falling, with damage previously reported… Southern Living, November 15, 2026: Your Neighbor’s Fruit Tree Hangs Over Your Fence—Can You Pick The Fruit?
Let’s say that your neighbor’s fruit tree is having a particularly productive season—so much so that branches laden with ripe peaches, lemons, or apples are hanging right over your fence, practically within arm’s reach. (And they look delicious!) It seems like a pretty harmless proposition to help yourself to a little of the bounty, especially if the fruit might otherwise go to waste. After all, it’s hanging over your property, right? But before you reach for that perfectly ripe fruit, consider the rules both of neighborly etiquette and the actual law. Is It Rude to Pick Fruit Hanging Over Your Property? The short answer: Yes, if you haven’t asked permission first. “Always ask for permission before obtaining fruit from any of your neighbor’s trees regardless of whether it is on or off your property,” says Beth Shankle Anderson, J.D., founder of Anderson Etiquette…
Two large limbs from the 400-year-old Davis-Meeker Garry oak tree in Tumwater that fell during high winds in September have been sitting in the backyard of the Operations & Maintenance facility for weeks. They will soon be distributed to four groups to become community and public use projects. The Tumwater Tree Board discussed the fate of the fallen branches during its Nov. 9 meeting. Sustainability Manager Alyssa Jones Wood said during the meeting that the two branches fell during a high wind event where speeds topped out at 54 miles per hour. She said the city decided to salvage the branches instead of sending them to the dump. But now Operations & Maintenance staff want their space back. Jones Wood said Mayor Leatta Dahlhoff requested that staff create an application and then score those applications for the Tree Board to decide who gets a piece of the historic tree…
Quaking aspens reproduce by sending up new shoots from their roots. Over thousands of years, a single parent tree produced Pando’s network of genetically identical stems. In a 2018 study published in PLOS ONE, Utah State University researchers Paul Rogers and Darren McAvoy assessed Pando’s condition and estimated that the organism holds more than 47,000 stems. The estimate builds on a 1976 study by Kemperman and Barnes, which mapped the grove’s 106.8 acre boundary from the air, measured stem density in sample plots on the ground, and applied that average across the site. Friends of Pando, working with the U.S. Forest Service through its Data Store project, is now conducting a more detailed census to replace those estimates with an exact count…
Per a recent Mountain Xpress article, since 2022, Asheville has lost roughly 736 acres of tree canopy — about 5% of the trees that shade our streets, cool our neighborhoods and hold our steep slopes together. Tropical Storm Helene took a devastating share of that loss, and none of us could have prevented a storm of that magnitude. But a great deal of the canopy we lose every year has nothing to do with storms. It comes down to a simple, avoidable fact: In Asheville, a homeowner can cut down almost any tree, at any time, for any reason — including a tree that took 80 years to grow, removed because a new resident doesn’t like the way it looks. This is a tragedy. That is a policy choice, not an inevitability. It’s one many other communities have already corrected…
Charlotte, North Carolina, Axios, November 12, 2026: 40 Charlotte-area sites have permits for tree removal near billboardsOf 154 permits issued statewide for tree-clearing near billboards, 40 are in Mecklenburg County, Sustain Charlotte founder Shannon Binns tells Axios. Residents, business owners and local leaders are concerned this could lead to more tree removal throughout the county after a stretch in Plaza Midwood was removed in October for an Adams Outdoor Advertising billboard. Sustain Charlotte and North Carolina State Sen. Caleb Theodros (D-District 41 Mecklenburg County) shared the list of 40 Mecklenburg County locations at a press conference Thursday in Plaza Midwood along with local leaders and business owners. Permit data was obtained from the North Carolina Department of Transportation Roadside Environmental staff, per NCDOT…
Christmas tree farmers are saying “bah humbug” to the forecast as their growing season finishes in an extreme drought. For people shopping for trees, the impacts this year will be minimal. Some trees might be slightly duller in color, but with proper care, they should last just as long as trees from other years. The real impacts will come when younger saplings are ready to be harvested in a couple of years. John Weston is a seventh-generation farmer and current owner of Weston’s Farm. He said that young trees need moist soil to develop a robust root system. “When the ground is saturated and wet all around the tree, it’s going to be much better. You’ll have a more nutrient uptake. You’ll just have a better-looking overall tree,” Weston said. Farmers can add water to the soil through drip irrigation or overhead watering, but it doesn’t soak all of the soil, which is what encourages root development. It also costs money and labor…
Early in 1971, Apollo 14 astronaut Stuart Roosa carried hundreds of tree seeds around the Moon, tucked into his personal flight kit. Back on Earth, foresters germinated the seeds and planted the young saplings across the United States for the nation’s bicentennial. Half a century later, mature trees grown from spaceborne stock still shade parks, public squares, and state capitol grounds. Roosa worked as a smokejumper for the U.S. Forest Service before joining NASA, prompting the agency to partner on the experiment. While crewmates Alan Shepard and Edgar Mitchell walked on the lunar surface, Roosa circled above in the command module Kitty Hawk with a mixed collection of loblolly pine, sycamore, sweetgum, redwood, and Douglas fir seeds…
When winter weather arrives, the landscape turns into a picturesque wonderland of snow and ice, but that frigid weather also means local deer will soon look for alternative food sources. Unfortunately, our beautiful trees and shrubs are often at the top of the list, becoming the focus of their winter browsing. Ahead, gardening experts explain the best ways to protect your trees and shrubs from hungry deer this season. It may not seem immediately obvious why a deer would want to chew on tough bark and thick stems, but these animals have substantially different digestive systems than humans. Deer have the digestive microbes needed to break down and release energy from the living parts of bark and woody stems…
A federal judge on Monday night refused to pause an order barring the Trump administration from cutting down more trees at East Potomac Golf Links, saying the government’s own planning documents confirmed that the tree removals were part of the president’s plan to replace the historic public course with a newly designed championship layout. The administration had requested U.S. District Judge Ana C. Reyes stay her preliminary injunction while it appeals her ruling to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, arguing that the tree removals were routine maintenance. Reyes said the record showed Interior had been planning “not to manage, but to destroy the historic East Potomac Golf Course,” replacing it with a new 18-hole track designed by Tom Fazio. Reyes wrote that the Interior Department’s recent proposal to the National Capital Planning Commission “confirmed” her finding that the tree cutting was tied to a plan to create a new course. She said the timing of the work “evidences bad faith” and “strongly suggests that the agency patterned its behavior to avoid judicial review.”The ruling leaves in place an injunction barring the government from cutting trees at East Potomac, except to address an imminent public-safety threat; the government must notify the court within 24 hours of taking such action…
A Toronto developer is facing new accusations of illegal tree removal at a residential property in the city’s west end. Modcity has faced numerous similar accusations in the past, and as of early September, the city had 10 open investigations related to the company. Now, four more trees have been cut down without permits at a property connected to the company. This time, in the Long Branch neighbourhood of Etobicoke. The affected trees include one that the city and locals previously fought to protect. The white fir towered above a two-bedroom bungalow, and had been the subject of neighbourhood walking tours…
Cultivating crops—such as wheat, barley and rye—alongside rows of trees is a system of agroforestry that is known as “alley-cropping.” It serves many functions: in addition to enhancing ecosystems and biodiversity, it can also counteract the negative effects of growing crops in treeless open land. The advantages of alley-cropping come from the interaction between trees and crops, resulting in improved soil quality, reduced wind erosion, enhanced nutrient cycling, and climate change mitigation through increased carbon capture. However, rows of trees can create competition for resources such as water, sunlight and nutrients, which negatively affects crop yield. A research team led by the University of Göttingen has now shown that, in systems with rows of fast-growing poplar trees, choosing between winter and spring crops based on the age of the trees can cancel out competition, creating opportunities for farmers to optimize their harvests. The results were published in the journal Agronomy for Sustainable Development…
Is it possible to prevent future power outages? Or at the very least, reduce the number of days with no power? DTE Energy thinks so. The company said contractors completed 56 miles of a planned 80 miles of tree-trimming work in the Grosse Pointe communities and Detroit’s east side, with the remaining work expected by the end of the year. It’s part of a five-year cycle to maintain the utility’s electric system across its service territory. “We know that about half of our outages are caused by trees,” said Bill Hutchinson, DTE Energy’s director of vegetation management. He said trees and branches can fall into power infrastructure, causing outages and creating safety risks. DTE describes vegetation management as one part of a broader grid-reliability plan that also includes infrastructure upgrades, automation and rebuilding poles and wires. Hutchinson said about one-third of DTE’s electric system is underground, but undergrounding can cost more and may require digging up yards or coordinating with road projects. DTE said it trimmed more than 3,000 miles of trees near electrical equipment across its service territory so far this year…
Trees are experiencing an “early spring” because of mild UK temperatures this autumn, with experts warning this could cause long-term harm to pollinators. Last month was warmer than average across all parts of the UK, with October marking the ninth consecutive month with above-average mean temperatures. Chris Nichols, the head of conservation outcomes at the Woodland Trust, said the mild weather this autumn meant horse chestnut trees were flowering and showing signs of next year’s spring growth more than six months early. During the extreme heat this summer, many trees underwent “early autumn”, where they wilted and lost their leaves prematurely. Experts said England’s ancient oak trees were dying as a result of high temperatures and drought, as trees and ecosystems struggle to adapt fast enough to the changing climate. Scientists have said the higher than average temperatures are only possible due to the climate crisis, primarily driven by the burning of fossil fuels…
Brilliant fall colors may be fading, but Colorado’s trees are still hard at work preparing for winter. And there’s a lot more happening beneath the branches than meets the eye. Just ask Elli Morris. Morris has a master’s degree in forestry and shares her knowledge through public education programs and guided tree walks in Southwest Colorado, helping people better understand and appreciate the trees around them. But she prefers a more whimsical title — “tree storyteller.” Morris joined CPR News for a walk along the Animas River Trail in Durango to reveal some of the surprising ways trees adapt to their environment. Trees have a clever trick for surviving freezing temperatures. As winter approaches, trees move some water out of their living cells and into spaces around them. That leaves behind a more concentrated, sugary solution inside the cells, which lowers its freezing point and helps protect them from damage. Morris compares it to the difference between an ice cube and a popsicle…
It is not until the New Year that people traditionally throw away their Christmas trees. But one event near Battle, in East Sussex, is trying to change all that by seeing who can fling a festive spruce the furthest before December even starts. Held on Saturday, the contest at Catsfield Christmas Tree Farm has become something of an official winter sport in the area since it originated in 2020, attracting competitors from all across the South East. Farm owner Clive Collins said: “The tree fling has become a much-loved part of our Christmas build-up, and people really do take the competition seriously.” This year’s showdown saw adult contestants tasked with hurling a six-foot (1.8m) Norway spruce, while smaller versions were used in both the under-10 and under-16 categories…
A deadly disease that affects Oak trees was recently found in a Wisconsin county for the first time, according to the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources. According to a social media post, a fungus causing oak wilt (Bretziella fagacearum) was discovered in a Mishicot tree in Manitowoc County. The most obvious sign of infection appears in mid-to-late summer, when infected trees prematurely drop branches with wilted leaves. The leaves are commonly partially green and partially bronze. Once a tree is infected, the disease can spread to nearby oaks through underground roots and, over longer distances, through contaminated beetles. The nearest known infection is in Brown County, about 20 miles away…
The Virginia Department of Forestry plans to install forest buffers for landowners near a wide range of water bodies. The program is part of the state’s efforts to reduce pollution and boost water quality. Riparian forest buffers are lines of trees and shrubs planted along waterways to help filter nutrients and sediments that run off the land. “In addition to slowing and filtering runoff, the many trees and other vegetation in riparian zones play an important role in reducing the likelihood of floodwaters reaching downstream areas that may be heavily populated and developed,” the forestry department states on its website. Buffers also improve the soil’s ability to store water and slow floodwaters. Virginia is launching the third year of its Riparian Forests for Landowners program, which partners with nonprofits, including the James River Association. The latest round is funded with $700,000 through the state’s Water Quality Improvement Fund. Private property owners in rural, urban and suburban areas are encouraged to apply, including civic leagues and homeowners associations…
Beech mast crunches underfoot, and the occasional conker catches the sunlight, tiny beacons leading me to Camp Hill, south Liverpool, with its distant views over the Mersey estuary. Goldfinches erupt from desiccated knapweed, and a flock of pink-footed geese fly overhead. For once, the birds are not my goal, but a tree: the tulip tree (Liriodendron tulipifera). Every autumn, the Camp Hill tulip tree flaunts its flamboyant presence: the Lady Gaga of the parkland. Named because its flowers resemble a tulip flower, and its leaves a tulip silhouette, few can resist its tulle lace canopy of butter-gold leaves. The luminescence is enhanced by the sheen of its leaf cuticles, and the fissured trunk adds yet more sensory impact. Yet this year there is a strangeness: instead of the golden monotone you would expect of this moment, there is a messy mix of different shades. Might the summer drought have disrupted the pigment battle between anthocyanins and carotenoids…
I haven’t seen many horror movies, but I have an idea for one: The protagonists are wandering through a forest—at night, obviously—when this monstrosity appears. It’s a four-wheeled logging rig called the HSM Project Outreach, and it has a ridiculously long arm that stretches 65 feet. In true thriller fashion, it even has a saw attached to the end. The entire flick is about them trying to outrun the machine. It is four hours long. Obviously, that’s a joke, but this contraption is not. A German consortium actually developed it for safety, not danger, as the idea is to “replace accident-prone manual work and make fully mechanized timber harvesting possible.” It does so by swapping the feed rollers that typically delimb trees (like this) for a felling unit that cut through several dozen spruce and beech trees up to 17.7 inches in diameter during a test…
A retired Navy SEAL commander from Sunapee pleaded guilty to a trespassing violation and paid a $1,000 fine after Sullivan Superior Court dismissed two felony charges over the removal of a tree and a stump along his lakefront property line. A grand jury indicted Michael Hayes, 55, in late May on two felonies: criminal mischief and timber-harvesting trespass, in connection with the incident, which occurred roughly a year earlier. Both felonies, which carry potential penalties of up to seven years each in prison, were dismissed by the court, with the state’s agreement, on the morning of Oct. 23 at his plea and sentencing hearing…
NO, YOU CAN’T TRIM MY TREE… BUT WHEN YOU DO, LEAVE ME THE WOOD
The Griswolds (no, not those Griswolds) worried about the heavy limbs of a century oak overhanging their place. Adrian, the arborist they had hired, got permission from the sweet old lady living next door, Clare, for a tree-trimming crew to come onto her property to trim the branches overhanging the Griswolds’ place.
Seems pretty clear-cut, a garden-variety Massachusetts Rule situation, complicated only by the need to use the neighbor’s place to gain access. What could go wrong?
Whatever grandmotherly Clare thought arborist Adrian meant by saying he was going to trim the oak, cutting limbs off was apparently not what she had in mind. Once the chainsaws started up, she suddenly concluded that she had never given Adrian permission to be on her property, and anyway, she had asked Adrian for the wood from the branches.
Huh? It’s kind of puzzling. If Clare had denied Adrian permission to use her property to trim the tree, how could she have asked him for the wood at the same time? It confused the jury, too, which found permission must have been given, and, necessarily, concluded that Clare could not be believed.
But seriously, wouldn’t a signature on an approval form have obviated six years of litigation? A cautionary tale for our time…
Beals v. Griswold, 468 So.2d 641 (Louisiana App. 4th Cir. 1985). The Griswolds lived next to Clare Beal, who had a beautiful, full 130-year-old oak tree in her side yard. Limbs from the tree overhung the Griswolds’ place. They hired Adrian’s Tree Service, Inc., to trim the overhanging limbs. While the trimming work was in progress, Clare protested excitedly, and the work was stopped.
Clare sued the Griswolds and Adrians, but the jury found for the defendants. Clare appealed, complaining that the jury should have found the Griswolds and the tree service to have committed trespass for entering her property to perform the tree trimming without her permission; conversion, for discarding the severed tree limbs despite Clare’s request that they be given to her; and negligence for failing to cut the tree according to Louisiana Horticulture Commission standards.
Held: The jury’s finding for the Griswolds and Adrian’s Tree Service was upheld.
Trespass in Louisiana is defined as any unlawful physical invasion of another’s property without the other’s consent. Here, the thrust of Clare’s trespass action is that the Griswolds unlawfully entered her property without her permission to gain access to the branches overhanging the Griswold residence. Although everyone agreed that the tree service’s workers walked onto Clare’s front yard and climbed the tree from her property, the crucial issue was whether she consented to their entry. Although Clare vehemently denied giving consent for the work to either the arborist or the Griswolds, her version of events directly conflicted with what the Griswolds testified to.
Arborist Adrian Juttner testified he had obtained Clare’s oral permission to prune when he inspected the property with the Griswolds to prepare a cost estimate for the job. Adrian said that after discussing the matter with the Griswolds, he approached Clare, walked outside in her yard with her, and pointed out the limbs he was going to cut. She said that was “all very fine and good with her.” The Griswolds corroborated this, testifying they had discussed with Adrian the need for Clare’s permission with Juttner, who then walked to Clare’s house and later returned to tell them he had received it.
The record contained adequate evidence for the jury to find that Clare had consented to Adrian’s entry onto her property.
But Clare complained that – oral approval aside – a trespass occurred because she gave no written permission to enter her property. In support of this argument, she relied on regulations of the Louisiana Horticulture Commission requiring every licensed tree surgeon to enter into a written contract with the property owner employing him to engage in tree surgery services and to obtain written permission from the owner before using “climbing irons” to climb the tree.
The Court said the regulations Clare relied on appear to require the tree surgeon to enter into a written contract with the property owner employing him. They do not require written consent from the adjoining landowner. Here, Adrian’s Tree Service gave the Griswolds a written memorandum, and that was sufficient.
“Conversion” in Louisiana is a distinct act of dominion wrongfully exerted over another’s property inconsistent with or in denial of the owner’s rights. Clare complained the jury erred in failing to award damages for Adrian’s conversion of the 800 lbs. of wood cut from the tree.
Clare testified that Adrian’s Tree Service disposed of the felled limbs and refused her request to retain them as firewood. Although Adrian acknowledged that Clare Beals had asked about firewood after the cutting had occurred, he testified that she was completely “irate and irrational” at the time of the incident and that he was not willing to expend the labor to chop up the branches, which were lying in the Griswolds’ driveway, and deliver the wood to Clare’s property. No evidence showed that any employee of Adrian’s Tree Service denied or refused to allow Clare access to remove the cut wood herself. Under the circumstances, the Court concluded that Clare had access to the wood and that Adrian merely refused to haul the wood back to her property. Adrian did not wrongfully exert dominion over the branches, especially in light of the evidence that Clare had earlier given her permission to prune the tree without mentioning her desire to retain the branches.
The Court further noted that the main thrust of Clare’s claim and evidence concerned her trespass claim. Evidence of conversion was sketchy at best, the Court said.
Finally, Clare proffered testimony by two tree surgeons to support her argument that the tree was not trimmed as required by Horticultural Commission standards of tree pruning. In contrast, the Griswolds’ tree expert testified that no damage was done to the tree in this case. The Court said photographs and testimony led to a conclusion that the tree is intact and healthy. Furthermore, the Court found that stumps remaining from the trimming may have resulted from Clare’s abrupt halt of the work in progress on the morning of the incident.
The jury’s judgment that there was no negligence was supported by the evidence.
There’s always a tension between the value that a lover of the land places on his or her trees and the price tag affixed to those same trees by the green-eyeshade crowd of financial experts testifying in some cold courtroom.
The general rule is that the measure of damages when trees are wrongfully cut should be the difference between the value of the property before the trees were removed and the value after the trees are taken down. Fans of the old case of the hairy hand (Hawkins v. McGee) from law school remember the general diminution of value concept. Notwithstanding this staple of first-year contracts class, courts in many states have carved out exceptions to the rule for situations just like today’s case.
The problem usually arises when only a relatively few trees of limited commercial value are removed or destroyed. In today’s case, an Episcopal Church lost 22 small trees when a contractor dumped too much fill dirt – taken from a road construction project – around their bases. The Church proved in court that replacing the trees — a couple of cherry trees and a score of red oaks — would cost just over $17,000. But the trial court threw the case out because it believed that the replacement costs weren’t relevant. Rather, the trial court said, the Church was obligated to prove how much less its land was worth with the trees gone.
The “tree volcano” … pile dirt around the base, and suffocate the sapling. The Church lost 22 trees this way.
Holy birch bark! The problem was that the property’s value hadn’t fallen much, since it was close to a road and of limited use (there’s not that much of a market for church properties). But the Church didn’t want the diminution in property’s value for its collection plate: it wanted its trees back. The Minnesota Supreme Court showed mercy to the Church, holding that where the trees served a primarily aesthetic function, replacement cost was a fair calculation.
Sometimes justice can’t be done by using the cold, analytical diminution-of-value approach. Occasionally, the wronged owner just plain likes the trees that had been taken, and who’s to say that because the loss may be measured psychologically rather than economically, the damaged party shouldn’t be compensated. We always thought that in such cases, the wrongdoer should be held to lose much of his or her moral standing to complain about how injured the injured party is. In this case, the Court said that the owner’s enjoyment of the trees might not be quantifiable in a real-estate-value analysis just didn’t matter. (The second case we studied in law school contracts, Peevyhouse v. Garland Coal & Mining Co., has always illustrated the mischief that can be done when a court ignores the aesthetic expectations of the wronged party).
The decision is necessary in the world of tree law because otherwise, too many cases would founder on the rocks of damages: too many malefactors could cut down too many trees, and the likely penalties, even with treble damages available, would not deter the conduct.
Rector, Wardens & Vestry of St. Christopher’s Episcopal Church v. C.S. McCrossan, Inc., 306 Minn. 143, 235 N.W.2d 609 (Sup.Ct. Minn. 1975). When the Minnesota Department of Highways took about 8/10ths of an acre from St. Christopher’s to enlarge the intersection, the church lost its existing access and part of its parking area. The Rector hired C.S. McCrossan to construct a new parking space and access road.
A grove of trees was located at the north end of the lot. During grading, McCrossan dumped fill around the base of the trees, which the church argued caused the trees—two black cherry trees and twenty red oaks—to suffocate and die. The church’s expert testified that because of the variety, size, and condition of the trees, they had a total value of $17,267.
The church asserted that the grove of trees not only screened the area from heavy traffic on two sides but also gave the area a natural, pleasing, wooded atmosphere. The trial court directed a verdict for C.S. McCrossan on the ground that the church failed to prove damage based on the diminution in value of the real estate.
The church appealed.
Held: The decision was reversed. The Minnesota Supreme Court ruled that the proper measure of damages for negligence in suffocating the trees was the replacement cost of the trees rather than merely the loss of value of the real estate, notwithstanding the church’s inability to prove that the destruction of the trees diminished the value of the property as a whole. The replacement cost of trees that have aesthetic value to the owner as ornamental and shade trees, or for purposes of screening sound and providing privacy, may be considered in determining damage incurred from the destruction of the trees, to the extent that the cost is reasonable and practical.
Although evidence may be presented in rebuttal that the effect on the value of land as a whole is minimal, it is for the jury to balance elements of damage in arriving at a just and reasonable award.